BBC Question Time faces backlash for LGBT education question

BBC Question Time faces backlash for LGBT education question

Friday, March 29, 2019

BBC political show Question Time has been criticised for airing a debate over whether it is "morally right" to teach children about LGBTQ+ "issues".

The question was raised on Thursday March 28 after news of continued protests at Parkfield Community School in Birmingham over lessons teaching respect for same-sex relationships.

The show came one day after MPs voted to approve LGBTQ+ inclusive guidance for sex and relationship education by a margin of 538 to 21, the first relationship and sex education guidance since 2000.

An audience member, Keith Broughton, was picked to ask panellists: "Is it morally right that five-year-old children learn about LGBTQ+ issues in school?"

The panel included Education Secretary Damian Hinds, Labour MP Jenny Chapman, Next chief executive Simon Wolfson, MoneyWeek editor Merryn Somerset Webb and academic Yanis Varoufakis.

However, after the Question Time Twitter account posted the question, many users questioned the way it was presented.

BBC presenter Sue Perkins tweeted: "The framing of this question is deeply worrying. Are we really here again, nearly two decades after Section 28 was repealed...?"

Perkins was referring to Section 28, an amendment abolished in 2003 which stated that authorities and schools should not "intentionally promote homosexuality or ... the acceptability of homosexuality as a pretended family relationship".

Debbie Laycock, head of policy at HIV charity Terrence Higgins Trust, told the Press Association: "In the week that MPs voted emphatically for LGBTQ+ inclusive relationships and sex education in all schools, it's disappointing this question was posed.

"What is 'morally wrong' is to deny information to pupils that they need to form healthy and fulfilling relationships in later life."

The charity also took to Twitter to praise the news that LGBTQ+ inclusive relationships education will be compulsory in primary schools from September 2020.

A BBC spokesperson said: "Question Time is a topical debate programme.

"This was a question asked by an audience member on a subject which has seen a lot of recent discussion."


Read more

Protests at school's LGBT lessons forces kids 'back in the closet'

Muslim parents protest after LGBT lessons taught at Birmingham primary school